It takes to create a legal person in the most efficient digital registries of the modern world, yet it takes an average of to legally end one.
This asymmetry is not an accident of geography or a temporary glitch in the software of the state; it is a fundamental design choice in the architecture of modern capitalism. We have spent the last obsessing over the “on-ramp.” We have celebrated the death of the paper form and the rise of the instant API.
The administrative gap: Why the entrance is a sliding door and the exit is a vault.
We have built dashboards for ministers to track how many new entities are birthed every Tuesday, using those numbers as a proxy for vitality, for “animal spirits,” for the restless energy of the entrepreneur. But we have neglected the exit. We have made the entrance a sliding glass door and the exit a vault that requires a three-man team and a blowtorch to open.
The Fire Stairs of Capitalism
I spent most of my thirties believing that this was the correct way to order a society. I was wrong. I used to argue, quite loudly in rooms filled with people like Ahmed W.J., a building code inspector who views every structure as a potential disaster waiting to happen, that the only thing that mattered was the “ease of doing business.” I thought that if you lowered the barrier to entry, the market would naturally sort out the rest.
I assumed that failure was a private matter, something that happened in the quiet of a living room or the back of a warehouse, and that once a business stopped trading, it simply ceased to be. Ahmed didn’t agree. He once showed me a blueprint for a high-rise where the developer had spent millions on a lobby that felt like a cathedral but had “value-engineered” the fire stairs into a narrow, winding chimney of unreinforced concrete.
“The lobby is for the sales team. The stairs are for the reality of the human condition. If you can’t get people out when the grease catches fire, the lobby is just a very expensive tomb.”
– Ahmed W.J., Building Code Inspector
MOST OF OUR REGISTRIES ARE LOBBIES WITH NO STAIRS.
We are currently living through a global experiment in administrative friction. If you have and a credit card, you can become the director of a company. You are granted the power to sign contracts, to hire staff, to lease equipment, and to incur debt. The state facilitates this with a sleek, user-friendly portal that uses high-quality typography and encouraging progress bars.
But the moment that company ceases to be viable-the moment the product-market fit fails to materialize or the co-founder departs for a “real job” with health insurance-the portal becomes a wall. Suddenly, you are no longer in the world of progress bars. You are in the world of liquidators, of tax clearance certificates, of “original wet-ink signatures,” and of professional fees that often exceed the total capital the company ever possessed.
This is the hidden tax on failure. Because we do not measure the time or cost it takes to dissolve a company in any of our major economic rankings, we have created a perverse incentive for governments to ignore the “back-end” of the business lifecycle. Its registry appears to be growing because the “zombie” companies-those that have stopped trading but cannot afford to die-remain on the books, padding the statistics of “active” enterprises.
It is a strange kind of dynamism that measures only the arrivals and never the departures. It is like a hospital that counts how many patients enter the emergency room but never tracks how many leave under their own power.
⚠️
The “Existence Tax”: Paying annual renewal fees for a company that hasn’t sold a thing in years, simply because the exit fee is too high.
Last week, I spent trying to open a jar of pickles. The seal was so tight, the vacuum so absolute, that it felt as though the jar had been designed to be a permanent time capsule for vinegar and cucumbers. I eventually had to use a hammer. It was a small, petty frustration, but it reminded me of the “seal” of a legal entity.
The Life Sentence of Paperwork
The consequence of this is not just a cluttered registry; it is a psychological weight on the entrepreneur. If you know that starting a business is an decision but ending one is a ordeal, you stop taking risks. Or, worse, you simply walk away, leaving the entity to rot in the registry, accumulating fines and penalties that you can never pay.
In places like Hong Kong, where the pace of business is theoretically breakneck, the “birth-death” gap is particularly visible. You can set up a structure, get a registered office, and appoint a company secretary in a heartbeat. But if you want to strike that company off, you must first prove to every relevant department that you owe them nothing, which is a process that requires the same level of forensic accounting for a defunct coffee shop as it does for a mid-sized factory.
Calculating the “Dead Loads”
If we were serious about building a “dynamic” economy, we would start ranking countries based on how quickly a failed founder can return to the starting line. We would stop celebrating the number of new registrations and start celebrating the number of “orderly exits.” An orderly exit is a sign of a healthy ecosystem; it means capital and talent are being recycled.
I remember Ahmed W.J. telling me about “dead loads” in structural engineering. A dead load is the weight of the building itself-the walls, the floors, the permanent fixtures. If you add too much dead load, the building can’t support the “live load”-the people, the furniture, the actual activity the building was meant for.
Every zombie company that is kept on the books because it’s too expensive to dissolve is a piece of dead load on the economy. It’s a secretary who has to file a return, a bank that has to keep a dormant account open, and a founder who has a “director” title on their LinkedIn that feels more like a shackle than a badge of honor.
Therefore, the ease of formation is not a metric of freedom, but a metric of recruitment. We need to redefine what a “business-friendly” environment looks like. It is not an environment where you can start a company with a thumbprint and a prayer. It is an environment where you can fail, clean up the mess, and start again without being buried in the wreckage of your previous attempt.
The real measure of an economy’s maturity is found in the efficiency of its
and the specialists who understand that a business deserves a dignified end.
If a government can verify my identity and my bank balance in eighteen minutes to let me in, it can surely do the same to let me out. Anything else isn’t dynamism; it’s just a very sophisticated way of keeping the registry full of ghosts. We have spent enough time polishing the lobby. It’s time we took a look at the stairs.
I think about that pickle jar often now. It sat on my counter for three days because I didn’t want to admit I couldn’t open it. I eventually realized that the seal was the only thing giving the jar its value, but once the pickles were gone, the seal was just an obstacle to recycling the glass. We are so enamored with the “seal” of the corporation-the legal protection, the separate identity-that we have forgotten that the vessel needs to be reused.
Ahmed was right. The fire exit is more important than the lobby. And until we put the processing time for a voluntary winding-up on the homepage of every government portal in the world, we are lying to every founder who clicks “Submit” on their first registration.
